Effective Altruism

Applying Reason to Do Good Effectively

Effective altruism is a social and philosophical movement that aims to use reason to research how to do the most good and to take action accordingly. 

EA is leading in systematically considering new priorities such as global health, animal welfare and the long term. Applying reason and a broadly utilitarian perspective can suggest new priorities that differ from our instincts, particularly due to our greater modern power, knowledge and interconnectedness.  

I regard EA as an alternative to political involvement as an approach to trying to change the world for the better.

Three EA Elements

I find it useful to distinguish three elements within EA thinking:

(1) Individual Altruism

The EA movement started from the idea that individuals should systematically donate to effective charities as these charities can be shown to produce benefits 100x the donor’s cost.  The charity evaluator GiveWell makes recommendations such as Against Malaria Foundation, whose bednet programme is shown by random control trials to save a life for around $4,500.   Giving What We Can encourages donors to pledge to give away 10% or more of their income, perhaps from a career strategy of Earning to Give. As well as making donations, the individual may choose his career to do the most good. 

(2) Effective Philanthropy 

Despite its thrifty beginnings, the EA movement has come to be supported by Open Philanthropy and other major donors and now has more than $40 billion of funding.  This gives the challenge of how over time to effectively deploy substantial funds to do the most good.  Many projects are now being funded, with a hits-based giving approach including some which have high potential but more risk.  The current main focus areas are global health and poverty, animal welfare and the future of humanity.

(3) Global Priorities

Beside the question of how best to do philanthropy, the EA movement also considers generally what humanity’s priorities should be.  Working out what matters overall is necessary for directing philanthropy, but the bigger effects from EA’s work may come from highlighting global priorities which leads to political change.   EAs have a unique new perspective on global issues with their universalistic and rationalist approach, while national politics gives little thought to issues such as global poverty, animal welfare and the long term.  It may be that EAs ‘think tank’ role, through organisations such as The Global Priorities Institute and books such as The Precipice, will be EA’s main contribution.

Valuable Ideas

Effective Altruism has already produced a number of very valuable ideas:

  1. Altruism can be very effective.
  2. Charity in the developing world can be one hundred times more impactful.
  3. Mental health matters.
  4. Factory farming is a great evil.
  5. The long-run future may be very valuable.
  6. Extinction risk is a great threat.

There is much impressive and energetic thinking around EA, and I can see many further important ideas being produced. 

My interest in EA

I came across the EA movement around five years ago through Peter Singer’s writing.  It was a revelation for me as it matched my long-held belief that reason should be used more in making good decisions and my view that international issues, animal welfare and extinction risk should be priorities.  But the movement is more than I could have hoped for in its people, its funding and the quality of its ideas.  

I have enjoyed learning more about EA through books, websites and podcasts, particularly the 80,000 hours podcast.  I participated in the online EA introductory programme in autumn 2021 and attended the EA Global Conference in London in April 2022.  I continue to keep up with EA-related ideas through EA newsletters, podcasts and the EA forum.

I find the whole range of EA ideas and projects interesting, but am particularly looking further into EA philosophical and foundational issues.  

Resources

My Writing

A Problem with Motivation.  An article for the EA Forum arguing that Effective Altruism should take into account that doing good is better motivated by norms than by willpower.

 

Books Reviewed

William MacAskill. Doing Good Better: Effective Altruism and a Radical New Way to Make a Difference. (2015)  The standard introduction to EA.  Good, but does not reflect how EA thinking has developed.

Toby Ord. The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity (2020) An excellent, comprehensive discussion of existential risks.

 

Other Resources

See the list of EA websites on the Links page.